FRESH

Hacker News

Clockss: Digital preservation services run by academic publishers and libraries

66 points by robtherobber

by uniqueuid

0 subcomment

Since it seems unclear what they do and why it matters:
Clockss seems to be an organization designed to make sure scientific content does not disappear library of Alexandria-style.
The most important task here is being legally safe, which is why they emphasize ivy league credentials, distributed nature, audits and so on. Technically it's not really difficult (except perhaps for dealing with publisher captchas heh).
They are legally safe because of this mechanism:
> Digital content is stored in the CLOCKSS archive with no user access unless a “trigger” event occurs.
All in all I think it's absolutely necessary.

by zvr

0 subcomment

I remember when the first LOCKSS papers appeared, the idea of "Lots Of Copies Keep Stuff Safe" was so obvious, once explained. The example used at the time was "can you imagine that we lose the Harry Potter book? No, since it's everywhere!".

by

0 subcomment

by yuvadam

3 subcomments

I've read several pages on their website and still have no idea what this is.
The ability of the internet to collectively archive content that is important to humanity as a whole - in fully distributed and legally questionable ways - is much more impressive IMO.

by lyu07282

0 subcomment

This would also be very helpful for datasets, we need to preserve those indefinitely in order to be able to make meaningful benchmarks in the future. Some datasets will only contain references to the source material and labels, each researcher is then supposed to assemble the actual dataset from those references.