by GMoromisato
6 subcomments
- This is a classic example of a simple idea that no one had ever done before. The execution was complex, of course, and Andrew McCarthy is one of the most skilled astrophotographers. But once you get the idea, a number of people could have done it--but no one ever did.
Makes you wonder what other similar ideas are out there! You can bet McCarthy is already thinking some.
p.s.: My brush with celebrity is that I saw an Andrew McCarthy post on Quora when he was first getting started with astrophotography and gave him a few tips. Always important to remember that everyone was a beginner at one point: https://www.quora.com/Are-there-any-pro-tips-for-astrophotog...
by loloquwowndueo
3 subcomments
- > The silhouette of Brown is neatly demarcated against the bubbling surface of the Sun. His downward trajectory is perfectly framed between sunspots, active regions on the surface of the Sun that are slightly cooler than their surrounding areas. This is not just a pretty picture; it is truly a masterpiece
Excuse me while I go wash off the stench of AI-generated descriptions. The picture is very nice, though.
- It’s a very cool picture. Andrew McCarthy sells prints of these and other astrophotography on his website[0] although they’re always limited run prints. I bought the one of the sun with a SpaceX rocket for a friend who is into astronomy.
As a sales strategy, making his photos limited edition is a fantastic way to put the pressure on to actually buy instead of thinking about making a purchase indefinitely, even if from a convenience standpoint it’s a little annoying. Looks like right now the 16”x20” edition is sold out, but other sizes are still available for about two days.
[0] https://cosmicbackground.io/pages/the-fall-of-icarus
- Is the full-sun photo edited to remove the paramotor? I just realized it was in the video shot - the head-down dive “tracking” position of the skydiver in the video happens only a few frames after jumping, only for a few frames, and after that he’s tumbling a bit against the sun, with the paramotor still visible. I’m guessing even if the video and still were two different cameras, they wouldn’t have been far enough apart to catch the skydiver without the paramotor?
- Watching the video, the difference between the actual frame captured and the manipulated stacked image that's being presented is quite stark.
- Better post IMO: https://petapixel.com/2025/11/14/sun-skydiver-photo-andrew-m...
- Related. Others?
I captured my friend transiting the sun during a skydive - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45919692 - Nov 2025 (12 comments)
by dazbradbury
0 subcomment
- Be great to have the same shot but in front of the moon. Photos would make a stunning pair!
by helsinkiandrew
0 subcomment
- I think the same photographers ISS passing infront of the Sun and moon are more impressive:
https://www.demilked.com/iss-in-front-of-sun-and-moon-andrew...
- Perhaps just me still carrying some latent trauma, but the upside down, legs bent moment reminded me of a picture from 9/11. Not going to link to it.
by cosmic_ape
3 subcomments
- Tbh, do not quite get the excitement around this picture. It was staged, and the stunt doesn’t appear to be particularly complex. A lot of logistics, sure. But seems like all there is to it is that someone just bothered to do it. So not clear what’s the additional value over photoshop.
- I’m get a box right away asking me to turn off my ad blocker. I’m not running an ad blocker…
- Very unique and cool image.
I was curious at first if this was planned, or if it was a bizzare coincidence… I’m not sure whether to be enthralled or disappointed. On one side is the wonderful creation of chaos, on the other is a marvel of photographic engineering.
- Am I right in thinking he flew up there in a paramotor and then jumped off it? What happened to the paramotor? It just crashed in a random place you have no control over?
- "what comes up must come down"
-- Icarus
- https://archive.ph/OrVxL
- I sort of like it upside down, power of ra.
by ZebusJesus
0 subcomment
- Great photo for science and art at the same time!
by ChrisArchitect
0 subcomment
- [dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45919692
by almosthere
0 subcomment
- I have to say, well done.
by NetOpWibby
0 subcomment
- Deus Ex: Human Revolution intensifies
by temptemptemp111
0 subcomment
- [dead]
- LOL - the deeper mythological meanings are quite applicable (!)
What meanings, a reader might ask? First to say, art and mythos can have layers of meanings..There is no "right answer" exactly. think for yourself a moment about "falling" "The Sun", "a son", endeavor, catastrophe, and add knowledge or fate as you see fit.
Hacker News