FRESH

Hacker News

Show HN: GitForms – Zero-cost contact forms using GitHub Issues as database

35 points by lgreco

by cxr

2 subcomments

GitHub is not Git. This doesn't really have anything to do with Git at all. This shouldn't be called GitForms.
The Git trademark policy says they don't want people to name things like this.
> you may not use any of the Marks as a syllable in a new word or as part of a portmanteau (e.g., "Gitalicious", "Gitpedia") used as a mark for a third-party product or service
<https://git-scm.com/about/trademark>

by altmanaltman

2 subcomments

How about email? Form runs on your (anything) -> creates a new email -> you get instant email notifications because it's an email. That's also perfect for MVPs, landing pages, portfolios or any low-volume use case. Why would I want to rely on a middleman or version control software for this?
If you know it's a glued-together solution that you'll have to rip apart if your program scales, why make it so complex in the first place?

0 subcomment

by lbatchelor

2 subcomments

by TrianguloY

0 subcomment

I personally use Google forms for a very similar feature. You don't even need to display the google form itself, you can create your own and then perform a fetch.
I even have it connected to a google sheet and google scripts, to send me emails for entries matching some patterns.
Heavily depends on Google, yes, but for something free that honestly I won't care if stops working (like a prototype) I'm ok with it.

by RadiozRadioz

1 subcomments

Neat hack, but it's free until it isn't. I worry about building things that rely solely on the good graces of Microsoft. Recent Actions news can support that skepticism.
Good that you've positioned it for prototypes.

by jyunth

0 subcomment

Pretty cool, goes along the same lines as Giscus, using GitHub resources to host comments. But after the recent moves taken by GitHub on the fees put on self hosted runners, I can't be too sure if these things will stick around for a long time.

by hi_hi

0 subcomment

Ha, I feel the pain. I built this a while ago to scratch a similar itch.
https://feature-refactor-for-cloudfl.first-contact.pages.dev...
It's no longer "live" so I wouldn't try and use it. I was using Supabase free tier to manage auth, and got tired of keeping it live. Good lesson learnt.

by lmssiehdev

0 subcomment

I recently found out about utterances which allows you to use GitHub issues to host comments, and I instantly thought of how this would be a good use case for forms.
Glad to see someone executing on this, and I love how descriptive the landing page is.

by jacobbennett

0 subcomment

by nonameiguess

0 subcomment

So, amusingly, a customer I consult for made a custom form submission application that is exactly this but creates issues in their private Gitlab rather than public Github.
It seems like you want to make this into some kind of viable business, and I don't mean to dissuade by any means, but this was a three-day project by a perfectly good guy, but one guy, extremely junior, that I was tasked with training on basic networking and systems administration duties. I don't want to speak ill of the man. I liked him a lot, but he was extremely hard to teach, could not seem to understand even the bare basics of how computers and the systems they collectively form when networked operate. But he could make this exact application, on his own, in a matter of days, before LLMs were a thing.
Not saying you can't manage it, but this is like trying to sell people sandwiches. Plenty make businesses doing exactly that, but you either need a captive audience or really good sandwiches, because most of the time anyone who wants one can make it themselves pretty easily.