FRESH

Hacker News

Kotlin's Rich Errors: Native, Typed Errors Without Exceptions

7 points by todsacerdoti

by cekrem

0 subcomment

The Java interop compromise is probably the biggest weakness of the proposal - it works beautifully within Kotlin but degrades at boundaries. This is similar to how Kotlin's nullable types (String?) become platform types in Java.
I think it's good nonetheless to add stuff to Kotlin that won't translate 1:1 to Java, both because Java is evolving but also because Kotlin is used in "Native" (non-JVM) contexts as well (not extensively, but hopefully that'll change).

by simon_void

0 subcomment

Rich Errors look promising to me, but what about interop with Java? What will the return-type of a function be on the Java side be, if the return type on Kotlin side is: Int | ParseError | SomeOtherError?
Background: unions aren't restricted to one normal type and one error type, but to one normal type and any number of error types, so this can't be modelled as syntactic sugar on top of an implicit Either/Result type, can it??