by pseudosavant
0 subcomment
- I’ve thought about doing something similar, but at the Service Worker layer so the page stays the same and all HTTP requests are intercepted.
Similar to the window.stop() approach, requests would truncate the main HTML file while the rest of that request would be the assets blob that the service worker would then serve up.
The service worker file could be a dataURI to keep this in one file.
- TIL about window.stop() - the key to this entire thing working, it's causes the browser to stop loading any more assets: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Window/stop
Apparently every important browser has supported it for well over a decade: https://caniuse.com/mdn-api_window_stop
Here's a screenshot illustrating how window.stop() is used - https://gist.github.com/simonw/7bf5912f3520a1a9ad294cd747b85... - everything after <!-- GWTAR END is tar compressed data.
Posted some more notes on my blog: https://simonwillison.net/2026/Feb/15/gwtar/
- I was on board until I saw that those can't easily be opened from a local file. Seems like local access is one of the main use case for archival formats.
- I would like to know why ZIP/HTML polyglot format produced by SingleFile [1] and mentioned in the article "achieve static, single, but not efficiency". What's not efficient compared to the gwtar format?
[1] https://github.com/gildas-lormeau/Polyglot-HTML-ZIP-PNG
- The author dismisses WARC, but I don't see why. To me, Gwtar seems more complicated than a WARC, while being less flexible and while also being yet another new format thrown onto the pile.
by iainmerrick
0 subcomment
- I agree with the motivation and I really like the idea of a transparent format, but the first example link doesn’t work at all for me in Safari.
- Very cool idea. I think single-file HTML web apps are the most durable form of computer software. A few examples of Single-File Web Apps that I wrote are: https://fuzzygraph.com and https://hypervault.github.io/.
- Pretty cool. I made something similar (much more hacky) a while ago: https://github.com/AdrianVollmer/Zundler
Works locally, but it does need to decompress everything first thing.
- It's fairly common for archivers (including archive.org) to inject some extra scripts/headers into archived pages or otherwise modify the content slightly (e.g. fixing up relative links). If this happens, will it mess up the offsets used for range requests?
- Hmm, so this is essentially the appimage concept applied to web pages, namely:
- an executable header
- which then fuse mounts an embedded read-only heavily compressed filesystem
- whose contents are delivered when requested (the entire dwarf/squashfs isn't uncompressed at once)
- allowing you to pack as many of the dependencies as you wish to carry in your archive (so, just like an appimage, any dependency which isn't packed can be found "live"
- and doesn't require any additional, custom infrastructure to run/serve
Neat!
by spankalee
2 subcomments
- I really don't understand why a zip file isn't a good solution here. Just because is requires "special" zip software on the server?
- I gave up a long time ago and started using the "Save as..." on browsers again. At the end of the day, I am interested in the actual content and not the look/feel of the page.
I find it easier to just mass delete assets I don't want from the "pageTitle_files/" directory (js, images, google-analytics.js, etc).
by westurner
1 subcomments
- Does this verify and/or rewrite the SRI integrity hashes when it inlines resources?
Would W3C Web Bundles and HTTP SXG Signed Exchanges solve for this use case?
WICG/webpackage:
https://github.com/WICG/webpackage#packaging-tools
"Use Cases and Requirements for Web Packages"
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-yasskin-wpack-us...
- The example link doesn't work for me at all in iOS safari?
https://gwern.net/doc/philosophy/religion/2010-02-brianmoria...
I will try on Chrome tomorrow.
by renewiltord
0 subcomment
- Hmm, I’m interested in this, especially since it applies no compression delta encoding might be feasible for daily scans of the data but for whatever reason my Brave mobile on iOS displays a blank page for the example page. Hmm, perhaps it’s a mobile rendering issue because Chrome and Safari on iOS can’t do it either https://gwern.net/doc/philosophy/religion/2010-02-brianmoria...
- [dead]
by nullsanity
3 subcomments
- Gwtar seems like a good solution to a problem nobody seemed to want to fix.
However, this website is... something else. It's full of inflated self impprtantance, overly bountiful prose, and feels like someone never learned to put in the time to write a shorter essay. Even the about page contains a description of the about page.
I don't know if anyone else gets "unemployed megalomaniacal lunatic" vibes, but I sure do.
Hacker News