FRESH

Hacker News

Show HN: I built an ISP infrastructure emulator from scratch with a custom vBNG

35 points by saphalpdyl

by yjftsjthsd-h

1 subcomments

Forgive my ignorance, this isn't my strong suit. Am I correct in understanding that this is mostly a simulation layer for the actual physical network, but that you're mostly(?) running off-the-shelf software on top? So this is running the same software that you'd use for a real ISP network, just without having to actually provision all the hardare? Or is part of the actual network management custom as well?

by john_strinlai

0 subcomment

this looks pretty interesting! i plan to take a closer look after work, but thought i would mention it now: it may be worth a look through the NANOG (north american network operators group) archives (https://nanog.org/nanog-mailing-list/list-archives/) for information around your question if you havent, and/or posting your question to the NANOG mailing list. there are many very friendly people who have experience running ISPs of all sizes.
(or whichever operators group best fits your area. i only subscribe to NANOG, so cant speak to the activity/friendliness of the other groups. you can find a pretty comprehensive list here: https://nanog.org/resources/organizations-our-community/)

by saphalpdyl

0 subcomment

I recently found out about Apache Netbox that would act as the authoritative source of truth for the network topology and replace majority of aether.config.yaml. In Splynx, I did not see any mention of an external solution. It seems they have their own stack for that.
A better and UX-friendly implementation would have been Netbox + aether.config.yaml -> configuration pipeline -> topology.yaml + <other generated files>.

by nonameiguess

1 subcomments

I feel like you were done dirty. When I was in grad school 12 years ago, our networking classes used mininet to simulate networks on a single host. It's mostly meant for developing SDN systems, but probably would have met your needs and supports way more.
On the other hand, building even a tiny subset but doing it yourself from scratch is a great way to learn. I made a very poor man's VM image builder for HyperV years back because Packer didn't have a builder for it at the time and that was a pretty interesting experience. Finally grokked the Windows object model and even though I still don't use it, I at least no longer jeer at PowerShell.
I'm interested in the answer to your question, too, but as a customer of an ISP. I don't work for one. I was the first owner of my house and when they hooked me into their network, whoever did messed up my neighbors badly, putting them on the wrong circuit and bleeding noise into adjacent neighborhoods. For three years, complaint calls would get our network cut by third-party contractors with no warning, then we'd have to call and get it reconnected. I don't know how they're supposed to do it, but know it can cause quite a mess when they do it wrong.

by bikesharing

0 subcomment