- This is great, and I'm not knocking it, but every time I see these apps it reminds me of my phone.
My 2021 Google Pixel 6, when offline, can transcribe speech to text, and also corrects things contextually. it can make a mistake, and as I continue to speak, it will go back and correct something earlier in the sentence. What tech does Google have shoved in there that predates Whisper and Qwen by five years? And why do we now need a 1Gb of transformers to do it on a more powerful platform?
- Nice one! For Linux folks, I developed https://github.com/goodroot/hyprwhspr.
On Linux, there's access to the latest Cohere Transcribe model and it works very, very well. Requires a GPU though. Larger local models generally shouldn't require a subordinate model for clean up.
Have you compared WhisperKit to faster-whisper or similar? You might be able to run turbov3 successfully and negate the need for cleanup.
Incidentally, waiting for Apple to blow this all up with native STT any day now. :)
by primaprashant
2 subcomments
- Speech-to-text has become integral part of my dev flow especially for dictating detailed prompts to LLMs and coding agents.
I have collected the best open-source voice typing tools categorized by platform in this awesome-style GitHub repo. Hope you all find this useful!
https://github.com/primaprashant/awesome-voice-typing
by cupcake-unicorn
5 subcomments
- https://handy.computer/ already exists?
by charlietran
0 subcomment
- Thank you for sharing, I appreciate the emphasis on local speed and privacy. As a current user of Hex (https://github.com/kitlangton/Hex), which has similar goals, what are your thoughts on how they compare?
- I see a lot of whisper stuff out there. Are these the same old OpenAI whispers or have they been updated heavily?
I've been using parakeet v3 which is fantastic (and tiny). Confused why we're still seeing whisper out there, there's been a lot of development.
by atlgator
16 subcomments
- This thread is a support group for people who have each independently built the same macOS speech-to-text app.
by konaraddi
8 subcomments
- That’s awesome! Do you know how it compares to Handy? Handy is open source and local only too. It’s been around a while and what I’ve been using.
https://github.com/cjpais/handy
- I see quite a few of these, the killer feature to me will be one that fine tunes the model based on your own voice.
E.G. if your name is `Donold` (pronounced like Donald) there is not a transcription model in existence that will transcribe your name correctly. That means forget inputting your name or email ever, it will never output it correctly.
Combine that with any subtleties of speech you have, or industry jargon you frequently use and you will have a much more useful tool.
We have a ton of options for "predict the most common word that matches this audio data" but I haven't found any "predict MY most common word" setups.
- Parakeet is significantly more accurate and faster than Whisper if it supports your language.
by kushalpandya
0 subcomment
- Speecg-to-text is basically AI version of Todo app that we used to build every week when new frontend framework would release.
- This got me thinking that the smaller these local first LLMs get - the more they're gonna looking the next bread and butter of app dev. Reminds me how Electron gained a lot of traction for making it easy to package prettier apps. At the measly cost of gigabytes of RAM, give or take.
by acjacobson
0 subcomment
- Nice app! Feedback since you asked: The most obvious must-have feature IMO is to paste automatically. Don't require me to hit a shortcut (or at least make it configurable)
The next most critical thing I think is speed and in my tests it's just a little bit slower than other solutions. That matters a lot when it comes to these tools.
The third thing, more of a nice to have is controlling formatting. By this I mean - say a few sentences, then "new line" and the model interprets "new line" as formatting, not as literal text.
by marktolson
0 subcomment
- I got it to transcribe this: "Create tests and ensure all tests pass" and instead of transcribing exactly what I said it outputs nonsense around "I am a large language model and I cannot create and execute tests".
Other than that issue I like it.
by __mharrison__
1 subcomments
- Cool, I've been doing a lot of "coding" (and other typing tasks) recently by tapping a button on my Stream Deck. It starts recording me until I tap it again. At which point, it transcribes the recording and plops it into the paste buffer.
The button next to it pastes when I press it. If I press it again, it hits the enter command.
You can get a lot done with two buttons.
- I really like the project and am eager to try and fit this into some of my workflows. However, this bothered me a bit:
"All models run locally, no private data leaves your computer. And it's spicy to offer something for free that other apps have raised $80M to build."
I’d straight up drop the comparison to big AI labs. This isn’t rebellious or subversive, it’s downstream of a ton of already-funded work. Calling it “spicy” is a bit misframed.
by fiatpandas
0 subcomment
- The clean up prompt needs adjusting. If your transcription is first person and in the voice of talking to an AI assistant, it really wants to “answer” you, completing ignoring its instructions. I fiddled with the prompt but couldn’t figure out how to make it not want to act like an AI assistant.
- If you don't feel like downloading a large model, you can also use `yap dictate`. Yap leverages the built-in models exposed though Speech.framework on macOS 26 (Tahoe).
Project repo: https://github.com/finnvoor/yap
- Can somebody help me understand how they use these, I feel like I'm missing something or I'm bad at something?
I only spent 10 minutes with Handy, and a similar amount of time with SuperWhisper, so pretty ignorant. I tried it both with composing this comment, and in a programming session with Codex. I was slightly frustrated to not be hands free, instead of typing, my hands were having to press and release a talk button (option-space in handy, right-command in superwhisper), but then I couldn't submit, so I still had to click enter with Codex.
Additionally, for composing this message, I'm using the keyboard a ton because there's no way I can find to correct text I've typed. Do other people get really reliable and don't need backspace anymore? Or.... what text do you not care enough to edit? Notes maybe?
My point of comparison is using Dragon like 15 years ago. TBH, while the recognition is better (much better) on handy/superwhisper, everything else felt MUCH worse. With dragon, you are (were?) totally hands free, you see text as you say it, and you could edit text really easily vocally when it made a mistake (which it did a fair bit, admittedly). And you could press enter and pretty functionally navigate w/o a keyboard too.
Its weird to see all these apps, and they all have the same limitations?
- Would also like to know how it compares to https://github.com/openwhispr/openwhispr
I like that openwhisper lets me do on device and set a remote provider.
- I've been using handy since a month and its awesome. I mainly use it with coding agents or when I don't want to type into text boxes. How is this different?
Part of the reason handy is awesome is because it uses some of the same rust infra for integrating with the model, so that actually makes it possible to use the code as a library in android or iOS. I have an android app that runs on a local model on the phone too using this.
- I currently use MacWhisper and it is quite good, but it's great to see an alternative, especially as I've been looking to use more recent models!
I hope there will be a way to plug in other models: I currently work mostly with Whisper Large. Parakeet is slightly worse for non-English languages. But there are better recent developments.
by hyperhello
1 subcomments
- Feature request or beg: let me play a speech video and transcribe it for me.
- Not sure why I should use this instead of the baked-in OS dictation features (which I use almost daily--just double-tap the world key, and you're there). What's the advantage?
by miki123211
1 subcomments
- What do you actually use for STT, particularly if you prize performance over privacy and are comfortable using your own API keys?
I was on WhisperFlow for a while until the trial ran out, and I'm really tempted to subscribe. I don't think I can go back to a local solution after that, the performance difference is insane.
by ianmurrays
0 subcomment
- I had Claude make this hammerspoon config + daemon that does pretty much the same, in case anyone is interested.
https://github.com/ianmurrays/hammerspoon/blob/main/stt.lua
- Interesting, I'm surprised you went with Whisper, I found Parakeet (v2) to be a lot more accurate and faster, but maybe it's just my accent.
I implemented fully local hands free coding with Parakeet and Kokoro: https://github.com/getpaseo/paseo
by maxmorrish
0 subcomment
- love seeing more local-first tools like this. feels like theres been a real shift since the codebeautify breach last year, people are actually thinking about where there data goes now. nice work on keeping it all on device
- Great job.
How about the supported languages?
System languages gets recognised?
- interesting, i wanted something like this but i am on linux so i modified whisper example to run on cli. Its quite basic, uses ctrl+alt+s to start/stop, when you stop it copies text to clipboard that's it. Now its my daily driver https://github.com/newbeelearn/whisper.cpp
- I think the jab at the bottom of the readme is referring to whispr flow?
https://wisprflow.ai/new-funding
- This is great. I'm typing this message now using Ghost Pepper. What benefits have you seen from the OCR screen sharing step?
by Supercompressor
1 subcomments
- I've been looking for the opposite - wanting to dump text and it be read to me, coherently. Anyone have good recommendations?
by therealdeal2020
0 subcomment
- btw I know at least a dozen doctors that still pay for software like this. I think doctors are THE profession that likes to use speech-to-text all day every day
- Sadly the app doesn't work. There is no popup asking for microphone permission.
EDIT: I see there is an open issue for that on github
- Oh dear, why does it not use apfel for cleanup? No model download necessary…
- How does this compare with Superwhisper, which is otherwise excellent but not cheap?
- how does this compare to macos built in siri TTS, in quality and in privacy?
by purplehat_
1 subcomments
- Hi Matt, there's lots of speech-to-text programs out there with varying levels of quality. 100% local is admirable but it's always a tradeoff and users have to decide for themselves what's worth it.
Would you consider making available a video showing someone using the app?
- is this the support group for people building speech-to-text apps?
I built https://yakki.ai
No regrets so far! XP
- very cool - huge open source drop!
by thatxliner
0 subcomment
- why isn't the cleanup done on the transcription (as opposed to screen record)
- MacWhisper is also a good one
by douglaswlance
0 subcomment
- does it input the text as soon as it hears it? or does it wait until the end?
- Hi, nice project! Quick question, when I speak Chinese language, why it output English as translated output? I was using the multilingual (small) model. Do I need to use the Parakeet model to have Chinese output? Thx.
- Well done
- [dead]
- [dead]
by jiusanzhou
0 subcomment
- [dead]
- [dead]
by aesopturtle
0 subcomment
- [dead]
by zhichuanxun
0 subcomment
- [dead]
- [flagged]
by atlasagentsuite
0 subcomment
- [flagged]
by joshuahart
0 subcomment
- [dead]
by edoardobambini-
0 subcomment
- [dead]
by zephyrwhimsy
0 subcomment
- [flagged]
by zephyrwhimsy
0 subcomment
- [flagged]
- [flagged]
by eddie-wang
0 subcomment
- [dead]
- [dead]
- [dead]
by lostathome
0 subcomment
- [dead]
- always mac. when windows? why can you just make things multios
Hacker News