- I like many of the ideas in this app, but IMHO it does not yet look like a macOS app: eg. strange blue focus outlines to denote active state, which on my system are larger vertically than the button they contain but not horizontally which results in a very untidy display, some buttons are smaller than the required/recommended minimum size. Some other things I've noticed, compared to Finder: far less items in the same vertical space, different keyboard shortcuts for same feature makes migration difficult.
My favourite Finder-likes: Nimble Commander, Marta
- does this index the disk to do this ? So the filemanager is working with an index rather than the files ? It could be stale ?
I haven't found a good file manager for mac since 15 years now. They all just about do the things I need but not good enough. I've never really done the dual pane thing, my favourite gui for file management was Windows XP. Every iteration of explorer since has gotten objectively worse.
On mac I don't even bother trying to filemanage. I remote in to a windows machine.
I need to be able to get paths and paste paths.
for my downloads I just sort by type in list view and delete whatever by type. just do that a few times a year no big deal. I don't understand why we can't have an AI that sorts out the files they half baked 'stacks' onto the desktop, but all that happens is i now have dozens and dozens of stacks which contain dozens and dozens of files.
by mune2gu-chan
1 subcomments
- The 9MB size alone got my attention. It's refreshing to see a native macOS app that doesn't pull in Electron for everything.
- I used to have a greater need for a file manager in other jobs. I don’t have the same need anymore but Forklift (https://binarynights.com/) has always been great and I still use it from time to time.
by ninefathom
8 subcomments
- //confused noises//
Wait, are you telling me that macOS has gotten so ensh---ified that many of its users feel the need to purchase a bespoke file manager, arguably one of the most fundamental functions of an operating system?
Surely this is a very specific product for a very specific class of users? This can't be a widespread need, right? RIGHT?
(Context: I haven't used modern macOS in roughly a decade and have no idea what it's like these days)
by seanclayton
2 subcomments
- Do you have any kind of public AI statement on the ways this product utilizes or is built with generative AI, if any?
by satoyoshidev
0 subcomment
- Cross-volume moves can't use rename(2), so they fall back to copy-then-delete. If the copy dies halfway, does it roll back or leave a partial file at the destination?
by kristianp
1 subcomments
- I'm not familiar with .net on Mac, what binding did you use to make this? .NET MAUI? https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/maui/developer-tool...
- Why would anyone trust an app from an anonymous source access their whole filesystem with read/write access? Who are you hello@whimfiles.com and where are you from?
- Just add an Up Directory button and you’ll be infinitely better than Finder.
- First screenshot on the front page has a design issue: text of selected file is in black instead of white.
- That's a great tool dude! I was looking for similar thing would give it a try
by thenthenthen
0 subcomment
- “Your Downloads folder has 847 files.” Oh no.. do I have a problem? +10k files
- I really, really need a better Finder. I've been using Path Finder for many years, but it was always a so-so replacement and the company wasn't very interested in moving it forward (even fixing bugs took many years). I eventually gave up and stopped paying for it.
I now use the Finder (column view) and it sucks.
At a first glance, I like this app. The problem I have is that I tend to think about the long term: will this app be around in 5 years? There is a plethora of AI-coded apps (this in itself doesn't bother me) where the author loses interest after just a couple of weeks.
And (here come the HN downvotes, because this is really unpopular on HN) the one-time pricing model doesn't lend itself to long-term sustainability, unfortunately. I know people hate to hear that, but ask anyone who tried to run a small or solo-founder business whether it's possible to make ends meet with one-time purchases.
by HeavyStorm
4 subcomments
- Just switched from windows to Mac and the rumors are true. Finder is terrible.
by farazzz123
0 subcomment
- [dead]
- [flagged]
by chonghaoju
0 subcomment
- [dead]
- [flagged]
Hacker News